[000:00:00;00] influence the decisions of at least the local government, yes you understand narva is a city in which 98% of the population is russian-speaking, so narva is less than the distance to tallinn point and eh yes this city is different let’s say that about a third of estonian citizens live there about a third of russian citizens and another third capital without eh without citizenship a-a and eh from down the third largest but eh third largest in which about 60,000 people live человек that is, this is not such a big city, ah, and ah, well, the whole region of the northeast takes into account that there is a compact russian-speaking population that lives there and watches russian television, because it is not

closed there, it’s not just a room antenna that catches everything ivan of the city and kingiseppa just like that nightingale a-ah and uh, there are several other points of view, and yes indeed, the numbers now said that this tank probably shouldn’t be introduced there now, because they are afraid of some provocations ah, i don’t agree with this decision, but i understand why they - why? they made such a statement . the fact is that parliamentary elections are taking place in estonia this week . they are going now and sunday will be the main day of voting. well, when the election will end. - for some actions that will affect it. of course, thank you very much for joining our broadcast, explaining the situation in estonia, in particular, yevhen kryshtofovych, director of the center for european

initiatives, was with us, for this we will say goodbye freedom life, we will come back tomorrow, taking the opportunity, please like this video, subscribe to the freedom page on social networks my name is sashko shevchenko and i will see you tomorrow i feel chained to the chair, everything is starting to annoy me , there is no convenient moment for pain, but there is a yellow cream dolgit cream dolgit helps to eliminate pain and has an anti-inflammatory effect dolgitz the only yellow cream for joint pain and for muscle spasms dolgit antispasmodic tablets for relaxing muscles and threads

cinema television port music education in free there is a choice, choose what you want on megogo, de-occupation. how can you do it? now you can’t. the history of the liberated cities of ukraine is gone . let’s see how our brothers helped us . they freed us from a normal life . nazis are here yes, we are here, we are all nationalists, people who resisted, residents came here, stopped and sent back and became heroes the novel is and will always be ukraine about unbreakable cities

of ukraine from the ukrainian project to the documentary cycle de-occupation every saturday at 11:10 on espresso the war raised its head again in europe , reminding us of the darkest hours of our history franz 24 constantly covers events in ukraine our team on the ground and in the studio will inform you about the dynamics of events this is the most relevant from franz 24 in ukrainian on espresso i congratulate you on the espresso channel i am yehor checherenda today we have a special guest and he is a famous historian, philosopher, professor of the ukrainian catholic university mr. yaroslav hrytsak p yaroslav i congratulate you today it is very popular to compare the two dictators putin and hitler, as well as the two nazi societies of the 30s and 40s of the last century, as well as modern russian

society. how correct are these comparisons in your opinion? every historian will tell you that every comparison is both good and bad, because every administration is a little lame there is because i said heraclitus you can't step into samoria river twice time changes and you know what you are talking about cyclicality there is no repetition in the history of the church i someone said that history does not repeat itself aside well we are in this there are definitely very important things to capture in rome, essential features that can be said that allow us to talk about putin's regime. as for the fascist one, there was a very good article, and i remember timati snyder's somewhere that i remember in po in may we will be studying in detail. the day simply lists the features of putin's regime which allows you to talk about it as a fascist for the first time the cult of the leader of funds is very important if you are not culparti are not very important how strange it is for fascism or nazism especially it is the cult of the dead i.e. the cult of dead heroes i.e. something it was very important and this death this death was somehow very important because this is the death

of people of something huge and big and we must respect these martha and what is very important we must give our lives without thinking and it is as if this ideology is very strong i also other things are obvious that there is a totalitarian regime that there is propaganda plays a very strong role that there is a clear image of the enemy and since for hitler it was the enemy of the jews for us for putin it is ukrainians and ukrainians completely where are humanized ukraine completely from whom you know not people it is not known what and especially used here in the image of bandera and konobrestki than us, there are many other things, but i think that one of the most important things is fascism together with nazism, because i think that the nazi part of fascism, and he looked back, his vision of the future was to return to the past to the reich, the third reich, which can be reminded of stryi rai, you know the society that was supposed to be unsustainable, such a baur society, in particular , the society was built in ukraine, where there is a lot of land, and it also does not offer

any future, then it offers to restore becoming a great russian empire is still about the state, that's another thing, and this one is very important . because you can say that the same features that i mentioned are the cult of the leader and, you know, propaganda and the lack of a position are also characteristic of stalin. this was the same, but the difference between stalin's wind was that what do you think, does it have any fresh future, this communism is a crazy idea , but it will be projected into the future, instead , a visa is required for this, you know in this hollywood film back to the future, yes, to the future, but let’s face it, we are moving forward. we look back on this and it is a very important thing to talk about fascism . well, there are certain things, certain things that are very important. your life, the most intimate areas of your life, and in particular, fascism will say nazism. how should you? excuse me, do you give birth , multiply, and everything else, because if we

see what moment, what moment is important in the propaganda of the russians, the fight against lgbt is very important, so let's remember the guitar to do it yourself, but in communism it somehow did not exist in the wind of this very clearly you know the proletarian cbt, god, fascism needs healthy families, what are the health of families for, what are healthy soldiers for, what is the health of soldiers, why should she be in the hospital if she wanted to conquer you that's all to fight well, the last thing that is with everyone is that the most immediate thing i think is the militarization of children, even children now have to be ready, ready guns, meat, and this is very clearly visible, you know these children who from kindergarten sit in different tanks there, these are lessons of courage they call it a check in schools, you know it's simple already, it's more of a crime that children are preparing the future of children from childhood , murderers are like that, that is, all these things are taken. can we talk longer here, can we go to some other topic to promote his propaganda, hitler

used radio and the press, now the world has changed, the internet has appeared , television has appeared, a person can learn about everything that is happening around him in the whole world bullets in one click, after opening the internet, how today putin and his propagandists manage to influence russian society to such an extent, to zombify russian society, there are two things and those things are very important. but putin is just as authoritarian as me, like the current chinese leader, like the hungarian orban , or even trump, it is very important that they are so-called spin dictators, they are not just dictators, they are dictators , they are common dictators, who are called that they are completely climbing, they are engaged in social networks you are very important to them, that is, it is very important that these regimes are starting to rule, and they are also drawing social regimes, this is not a network, let's not forget

that in russia, under the prohibitions, what was wrong, youtube is already banned, it was banned, that is , all connections to facebook are considered prohibited , all alleged substitutes are used, substitutes for this should be russian e just as in china, as well as in russia, in order to access some youtube, you need to perform these proxy proxy addresses, this also says, that is, they understand that it is very important to specifically control the mass media of the original television because it is also important, we understand that one of the steps is to raise putin to power or take control of all the mass media, because now all these oligarchs are oligarchic or have given away their television or serve putin, but the second step is control over all these social boundaries of communication facebook youtube or are all others of the same age and you, all the others , it is also very important for them . it is given to them.

to say everything is more effective than before hitler to do all the same more moscow means well besides all that it must be said that hitler had more charisma than than putin has mr. yaroslav how can you compare the charisma of the two fuhrers hitler and putin how ideological are people we don't know that we can't say, you know, we need to judge here , we lack documents, maybe in 54 years, when it will all be over, god forbid someone will see the documents, we will understand later, before the authorities how it was, but you need to understand one thing and this it may be very important, according to the question, that there is such a long-standing belief that putin came to power and manipulated russian society, in fact, no, in fact, the researcher shows that russian society really wanted someone like that. it is not by chance that the elite who chose for themselves someone who wanted to be a member of the communist party wanted a very useful such as i am his price as putin, someone relatively young , relatively and all kinds of swedes, there are security services who don't drink much

. in russian society, she is a solid year, and actually then as a result of this firm hand, of course, putin has that charisma, but you can say as you know, charismatically, i think that there is still a child, that um, putin is putin's ideology, it is not so expressive, after all, hitler's it was very all the way, but i'll take those times, when the 30s, it was all putin's, come on , everything is smeared, but we know orthodoxy and the fascism of imperialism. what a thing makes putin look like a guitar. i think that comparing hitler with putin is a compliment to putin. because putin does not reach for the guitar, because all the same, what did the wind, the wind was able to modernize in germany , the wind created a huge economy in germany and on this basis he built a huge army under hitler there was a huge economy one of

the largest economies in europe under putin nothing is worth luciana’s big bubble he has oil and gas there he can do some things because i don’t but to see you know the level the level of poland is at the level of russia, the huge country achieves in terms of its volume of traffic regulations pdf only in spain. and in terms of living standards, even portugal can find out. one of the features of the modern way after the defeat of hitler is that the war in the first world disappeared , we went around the first world before , france and germany fought. the third world is very important, and now it is actually very important that putin is the third world , that is, putin, you know, he is weak economically, but he is puffing up, because it is very clear that he would not be able to analyze in russia, this is a failure

, a complete failure, russia, you know. well, you probably remember the story when to try russian silicone, what was the end of it, that is, it is very important for putin to compensate for his economic failure with war, and it is important that it was evaluations for hitler, otherwise it would have been a strong economy and a strong war, significantly let's look at the russian treasures fighting in the human army, completely new like the german army. i don't want the german army to fight, but you remember that the german army passed through ukraine in two months, and here the russian army is trampling on this territory for 5-7 km a month in at best, and very often they happen backwards, that is, i express once again i think that comparing putin to the wind is a compliment to putin, both putin and hitler were admired by a lot of people from the world of business and the intellectual world, how did they succeed in what

their phenomena and when disappointment came, i don’t know a lot of fertilizers, enchantment in the end, the ukrainians were enchanted, the truth is not as windy as mussolini ’s, the ukrainians believed more that our ukrainians here in galicia more believed that muslins will reproduce this spirit of elevation , you know, the nation says to set fire to some kind of height, but yesterday they were already obvious because it was such a time. and 20-30 years ago, we all remember almost all of us. who were the great leaders of this time, the great führers, if not stalin, then mussolini, if we are a musulta hydra, so that it is not a crucible, then a convict and we have it almost everywhere in britain, but britain, you know, they laughed about it all the time, britain was, let's say, 30 years divided, fell under the influence of communism or the nooses of fascism. it was very clear, brothers , it may have disappeared if it is very important that the only country that did not succumb to the temptation neither communism nor fascism it was britain where the workers played the british workers dispersed by marching the fascists british which is very important shows but the british believed that it was a sign of their racial superiority that i have such

stupid europeans who fell for it, but there was admiration, admiration was very, very, very general , we don’t know how deep the real admiration for er putin of russia is 35-40% of such poutine are mixed in russia. and this is real and they really want a war and they want a glorious end and time they are even ready to follow putin, that is, even putin and me as well as others, this is the majority, of course there is a certain number of 10-15%, which is quite a lot in germany , there were not so many people who do not like putin, hate them, all the others are like that, because the opposition would have left, or i am sitting in a swamp. it was, it wasn't, germany was mobilized, the number of those who fly is very, very, very, very not significant, the wind really owned that society, you have he said because he gave he gave a very important conviction to the germans, you know the germans, which had to be done en masse

, suddenly all the germans had a job who got about it is not said now, he then the germans got paid vacations for it, the idea of ​​volkswagen is hitler's idea, that is, everything is for the people with such populism, i'm fighting for god, i don't care about it, don't think that the wind is coming, but it's very important hitler it was very important, that is, the wind did not just go to power the wind without stopping raised the standard of living of the germans. so, hitler's germans were captured. because you know it was really caressed by the elements, only they did not answer in the way of this, because russia, that i am now a poor country in the world, let's look at these photos or that all the rest of us see how people live outside moscow and outside petrograd, so i think that in that sense we cannot compare, that is , putin, although he may wish for a dream so that we could accept it, but he must, he clearly does not reach this level, is it possible to modern fsb kdb kgb nkvd to be compared with the ss or the gestapo of the times of nazi germany, this is the cult of this mysterious order, are there any parallels

, the comparison is definitely because the actual nkvd chek and fsb they have a cult and have a lot of strange things that are similar to the gestapo, the ss begins they really believe in the books, that is, most of them, well, they say that i can’t get into their heads, but many of them can , most of them have all kinds of strange ideas, enlightenment, they are considered that the world, uh, they don’t exercise some kind of democratic process in the maidans. conspiracy theories from the language, you know, it’s some kind of deep , deep spy games, they disbelieve themselves, and putin himself is like that, you know, from broadcasting they don’t need reality , nobody’s estap, the nkvd doesn’t need reality or it creates reality on its own like they are they are they they demand this, this, that’s the only difference. it seems so to me, and again it seems to me that i cannot say such documents , first of all, the fsb does not have the strong ideology that the ss should have received, although it is some kind of tapas , of course, it is beautiful.

this biology, and secondly, the level of corruption, the level of corruption of the fsb is much higher, it is a cynical council, do you know this scumbag , the fsb cynical gestapo or not, how not to get children, something else . believes so much in all these ideas of putin, but then create not the whole society for them, but exceptionally comfortable living conditions for them, and this condition alone tells why a russian cannot rebel now, because under putin, this apparatus has grown so much, as you know, the rest of the opryshniks, he is so big class and so strong mainly by all privilege we all others to putin that he will protect the last blood, you know, except that all the big ones are about the same thing that lukashenko has with those of his own, you know special specials like ours once berkut or something else that was given to us, that is, it seems to me in the sense that there is a comparison, but it is a peculiarity of the russian case , that i think ukrainians are very good, good, good

, because they call russians names, ukrainians call the regime of russia not a fascist arashi , because it means that i have similarities, but especially russian russian features of the russian feature is a huge box of corruption." are dictators putin hitler afraid of death and what are the consequences of this fear the wind was not afraid because the wind thought it would be immortal of course, i don't like how a person believed that he was creating an immortal thing, outside the immortal reich, and for hitler, you know, it really was a cult of death, he believed in kuchma death, because he believed that everyone dies only physically, but even forms into its own great reich, nations are like that, all that belong to them, that's why of course, my mother was not putin, now you are scared to death, this time they are a very physical person, there is the very fact that he has not been hiding in a bunker for how many years, do you know what is also

possible, as there is a hiter, he was not afraid of an assassination attempt , the wind was constantly present in velikiy on the streets, we see these pictures, you know, a hyper pen, and it’s with people taking children in their arms, everyone else, we see it right now , you know, and you don’t fear it, you can see that putin is clearly sitting in bunkers, you know, these bunker children who say that he is worried about his life too, everything is very noticeable, he does not come close to the battlefield , we remember, again, the wind had one of the highest nearby stakes, that is, vinnytsia is so close, closest to the front, he liked the guitar , the guide didn't like to take risks, the hydra took risks in them to take risks because he was a very human, how to say again, i don't care, hyper struggle, wind, criminal, there is nothing to say, but these lack of direction, acceptability, er, uncompromising , ideological er, idiocy, you can say that hitler was much higher than putin than putin so gross and disgusting because we understand that he plays a role, he plays

it very badly, he would like to be that, but we see that he clearly does not succeed in this one . that is, we can say that putin is a chinese copy of hitler, yes. well, i don't know if the chinese one to call chinese, to call worse quality, i don’t know, because we are now seeing very dangerous processes in china, because i see that the chinese can create 10-10 through russia, and a cat, because their current leader of russia looks like such a future of putin, he broke it the constitution is also putin's, he went for a third term, he is already at the age when he clearly starts spraying weapons and the situation is very similar. although there is a difference , we can clearly see that the economy is overheating in china. there will be economic difficulties, which means that there is a big threat that when there are economic difficulties, when i want to stay in power, he will dream of a victorious war, and here you have it. and this is the worst situation for the world and for taiwan and for ukraine , because the emergence of a second outbreak of war can

divert the attention of the west, but that he is here, it is important to reduce aid, that is why it is very important, i do not eat, everything will not happen, and it will not happen to you , i really hope that the fact that the ukrainians are winning at the front . try or taiwan has no business if you leave it now, but who knows, but you are talking about a chinese copy. it seems to me that now all attempts are to copy putin, but in that sense the most successful. therefore, everything is like he has an economy and things like that, maybe we will see. i recently watched alone documentary film there was an archive archive video with putin from the time when he was just elected president of russia and he said that he did not want to become a tsar, that he still wanted to return to his previous life sooner or later it would happen whether he wanted to or thought putin was already planning to become the king, we don't know, we don't know, we don't know what putin was doing today, and we can't know, but we can see the logic of events, these books are whole, what book is serhiy gureva about, spin

dictator he says that actually there are four this book. the new generation, they are not hitler, they don't want to be like uh, it's very important. these are populist leaders, and they are, let's say that orban is a sherdugan, that putin, that they all have the same trajectory, they come to power in a country that is uh, in anarchy weakness and when in a very strong situation arises in society due to the push of someone strong who will come and bring order and they carry out order and it must be said that the minimum order is starting to work because things are really going for the better the economy is rising like this everything else but what else do you know suddenly this society feels better than it was before, and here you know the situation arises as a wizard’s apprentice who is absolutely not available to be employed because of the increase in the standard of living, so far life is spent until the emergence of a creative middle class, and these cells are special class

he just wants to use, i want to go abroad, he wants to have freedom of speech, he wants to express himself, it is very important and you think everything is a creative classic that is starting to perform and almost everywhere we see what is in china yes no mines what what what in istanbul taxi square what in moscow bolotna what in belarus in the 20th year of the protest that there are two maidans in ukraine, that is, the lumbar situation comes to the point that such authoritarian people as yanukovych, dogan or someone else have fewer and fewer chances. it is especially important because we can keep the government on the periphery in the hinterland, which is poor, but you can't get it in the cities, the biggest cities, let's say kyiv, minsk, istanbul-moscow, does it need councils , because there is high creativity, this is high , simple, operational class , universities, academia, various centers, it sectors, all the others, and then comes the second stage, the second stage you start that this one comes to power and suddenly he was so handsome popular suddenly they start to press the position you know with a flamethrower i know for sure what you are putting in prisons

exterminating such and such all others zero such all others and it turns into such and such a real despot, but everyone understands that you know that if it was about russia in the background of connecting economically, that is why the book is already in decline, that is, the sleep of repression passes together with pat or really ends and then the fact arises that in fact this leader turns out to be a splattered trough, he has nothing to lean on because he is not that popular, nor is he broken in terms of the position of the economy. there it is, and what seems to you is the third stage and he has to resort to external aggression, then come the idea of ​​a small victorious war, then against georgia. now about ukraine, because this is the only way for him to hold on for the rest of his existence , so we don't know what was in putin's head from the very beginning, but general logic when they pass into your firm hands to those who en masse drive everyone into the army and turn them into they are cannon fodder and sent to some foreign territory to fight for this dietary leader. can we say that the length

of time a dictator is in power affects the amount of blood on his teeth? a dictator leads a certain country, the more bloody he is, and yes, as if you know, the guitar was about 12 years ago when he was in power, he had a lot of blood, especially in his hands. that's why we have to warn against the belief that all these leaders must end badly, not after that, so far 10 to shpyki live to death. well, you can study there, you know, even though we took him there, we took him very much to death. therefore, this does not mean that you know what if you plug somewhere whether it will fall low by itself, it may fall, it may not, there should be external factors that are allowed. everything, i think that in that case , our part is very important for putin to hand in his sentence against ukraine . perhaps he would have them exist even longer and for 10 years 15 years, but now, having started this war, it is obvious that his regime

will shrink very, very quickly. hitler was already driven to his bunker in may 1945, as a result of which he committed suicide. well, according to the official version, together with his wife eva braun, is he driven now putin and what he is capable of, and if hitler had nuclear weapons then, did he use them before his death, and can putin do it now , in fact, this is one of the questions. it took a little more time for the germans to use these weapons, because it is said that if the analogy is that what now has, now putin has someone . it ’s a good joke. you already know the difference between putin and hitler. not still does not impose because putin has passed his own picture in which he believes this picture has little to do with reality imagine a person who does not read or does not go to google finds finds and in general

it uses the internet that is, it is a common problem, the problem of everyone all such despots are tyrants, but putin has an especially putinstve environment around him, which brings him only good news, because everyone knows that now whoever brings bad news is killed, it learns, you know, there are messengers, and he one must know the feeling, he continues to think that everything is going well, this indicates that he continues to think very well, and you know how much in that bunker he imagines what is going on and, well, this one, well, besides all that, someone even wrote it, it is already a personal thing, this does not have a comparison with hitler, it’s just that someone once argued about putin’s philosophy, they name different people who influenced putin , ilyina shmid and all other such things. they said very well, in fact, putin’s philosophy. putin is a boy from the suburbs, you know the same, gopnyk well, there is no need to exaggerate his intellectual capacity, he does not have any deep intellect , but he is here, philosophy, philosophy of judo, and judo is a philosopher , which means that you can. you can overcome your

opponent in any way, fighting him endlessly until he falls. you can say shvatka bulldog or some such mastiff dog, you know, hold it, don’t let it down , and this is putin’s logic. putin will hold it for so long, and there will be a lot of work to do , well, while he can fight with ukraine or with the other regime has a very important parallel, i didn't think about it, but i read it somewhere recently and thought that it makes sense . look, we always think that democracy is better and it is definitely better, and it is better that it wins tomorrow in that all, but this is not the end, because we see that liberal democracy, which was born after the first war, then almost everything is normal from the top with the last prefix of the holy democracy . is it possible in slovakia and france? i'm an idea like that in reality what really saved democracy, and it is also very strange that the two largest countries , the most successful and economic, were ideal for political love, entered the war on