but in my opinion, the white guard is a masterfully written novel, but this novel is very secondary, in my opinion, it is not an experimental novel, on the contrary, the city is an experimental, then a modernist novel, well, let literary critics criticize me for this, if they do not agree with me , i think so, i like it, i don’t like it, that’s another question, it’s a ukrainian-language modernist novel about our city, another question is interesting, there is another russian-language novel about kyiv, which was written by a kyivan who loves kyiv, it’s in his hometown, in the hometown of nykrasov , why do these people of bulgakov, yes, these fans of russian-speaking kyiv, do not mention the fact that only a sign hangs in nikrasovo, it seems, in the passage where he lived, there is no museum, and there are no references, despite the fact that in his native garden it is written with great love for kyiv, and if there are any fans of russian literature still here , let them get along better with viktor nikrasov, why not viktor nikrasov?

because bulgakov, despite his alleged anti-bolshevism and anti-communism, is inscribed in the russian imperial canon, absolutely entered, or rather he sought to be entered, that is why he writes about stalin, batum, and, he, he, he, a sycophant who tries to fit into this new communist canon, and does not fit in, and, by the way, interestingly, bulgakov on the 21st, it will happen, well, correct me if i'm wrong, on the 21st. when he flees, he flees to moscow, although the white emigration he sings of does not flee to moscow, the white emigration flees, and he has a play about the white emigration was not stalin's favorite, and it flees to where, it flees to paris, to europe, and nikrasov, 70s years, when it was much more difficult to leave the soviet union, he leaves and lives out his life in exile in paris, not in the soviet union. given, because he did not fit

into this imperial canon, bulgakov fits perfectly into the imperial canon, as a chauvinist, as a xenophobe, and he has a place there, so here is the problem we started talking about, bulgakov is clearly a russian writer, and this is unambiguous very dangerous russian writer, then this is not our bestiary, no, this is not our bestiary, nikrasov is a russian writer, but he loves kyiv, he writes about kyiv with love, he writes a very ambiguous novel, i don’t know at all, maybe because he received the stalin prize for in the trenches of stalingrad, he was given the opportunity to print, print this novel, which was then completely destroyed, and read it, i don't want to spoil those who haven't read it, but again, despite the fact that nykrasiv is a kyivan who writes with love about kyiv, this is part of russian literature, and it should be treated that way, and today it is also dangerous , precisely because it is talented, written, and about bolgakova too, but again... knows that

there will be screams from the fans here, it seems to me that he is generally a very overrated writer, he is the number one star only in this russian corner of world literature, because those who fight with masters margerit margarita and, oh my god, read hoffmann's elixirs of satan, read the angel of the western window, that is, i think we all read it very young, for example, when i read it in the second year. no, so that you, so that you understand, right? that is, when you, i, when i reread, i rewatched, i understood what it's not as strong as it seemed to me at the time, that is, for a 20-year-old child, and a young person, it can be wow, and then you understand, it's like a steppe wolf, german, and at 20 years old you get excited, then, no questions,

but it is not the genius of humanity there, and it is very overrated in our country, because it is not so well known in the west anymore, and why does it trigger so much, why so much, why such storms, now was the conclusion of the institute of national memory , yes, regarding the inadmissibility of glorification, which screams started again, as you say, so immediately there was a museum. could to provoke, i read it before it was on the air, it is written in a terrible language, such a national language, that is, i agree with the message, but how it is done and in the same place , mostly the reaction, how it is done, but also the answer of the museum, it can also be there to find many internal contradictions, i say again, we are... a democratic country despite the terrible

war that russia is waging against us, and that russia is waging against us, and we cannot ban writers, the question is not that whether we banned bolgakov or not, we didn't let's... go to private libraries and take out these books or burn the books of russian writers in the squares, as they do with ukrainian literature like real nazis. the question is not that, the question is that bulgakov, who is pushkin, this is an imperial marker, there cannot be monuments to these imperial writers on our streets, it cannot be, i would, for example, the museum should be preserved as a research center, or i b, for example, called it the museum of research, research. someone of chauvinism, for example, yes bugakov is a chauvinist, a chauvinist, but not only him, i imagine what the reaction would be, terrible, maybe it would be terrible, but i am so radicalizing, you can find a formula, and researchers should

investigate, i even had such a metaphor once, that what is russia, it is a plague barracks of history, but who should go into a decent barrack, well, to treat, why do you need to treat? uh, doctors risking their health and lives, writers, philosophers, historians, social researchers, even psychiatrists must also enter the cultural conditionally plague barracks of history, yes, because i am certain that this also a mental perversion, if a person is proud and says that i am russian, well, today i am okay, but there are schizophrenics, there are maniacs, and someone has kidney diseases, you need to see a doctor, yes... if it is a person with pride , if he says this with a sense of guilt, then, well, then you can still listen to this person, but i have not met such a person, so it is necessary to investigate, it is impossible not to investigate, the enemy must be known, but it should not be a subject on our land, and when we erect monuments, when we name houses, when

we open or preserve museums in honor these people, then we simply mark the presence of the russian empire here, which is already killing us physically, look, we have three minutes left. i can't help but ask about another initiative, also written in very interesting language, so there is a position, there is such an initiative group, which arose, as i understand it, in the bowels of the kyiv music academy, yes, we say, tchaikovsky conservatory, yes, an initiative group was created , which says that it is necessary to return to ukrainian culture people who have ukrainian roots. despite the fact that they even created imperial culture, for example, they say about chekhov, aivazovsky, kuindzhi and, i quote, a descendant of the cossack family of seagulls, tchaikovsky. there is a lot mixed up here, but it is simply interesting to find out what you think

about this initiative, because there are also quite decent people who signed it, for example, akhtem saitablai, viktor yushchenko, and just as many other cultural figures that you do you think about this? well, first of all, we have to understand that if we treat the questions of history as scientists, and this is a question of history, then the argument is ethnic origin, it is not scientific, it is a kind of primordialism, that ukrainianness is something that is given from birth, it is a soil of blood, well, then i am not ukrainian, but i have very little ukrainian blood, so i am a constructivist here, thank god , a clear majority of our modern historians, and i repeat more than once. this formula of benedict anderson , the nation is a narration of nations and narrations, nations are products of the public imagination, and therefore it matters in what language we form these ideas, and it does not matter so much where a person was born, you can be born in ukraine, have ukrainian last name and to be a russian nazi, as we

see a lot of people who are in moscow today, ethnic ukrainians, they are calling to kill us, is this not an initiative to simply save the seagull and i think it is commercial. i think that this is generally a commercial initiative, because it is necessary to sell seats for foreigners, let's say, there are those who want, i know, many chinese came to study, and tchaikovsky, yes, tchaikovsky this label, but it is a russian label, that's it you won't do anything, tchaikovsky, although literature is easier, there the marker is language, with music it is more difficult, although again, why is it more difficult, the most famous operas of tchaikovsky, they are connected with russian plots, yes, let's not discuss it now, and with russian literature. yes, well, ballets are different, and as you know , he conceived the swan lake in bavaria in the south of bavaria after seeing this lake near the castle, but tchaikovsky, we still have to

understand the historical context, tchaikovsky is perceived everywhere as a russian composer, and we remember more do you remember when we were there? swan lake when it dies the next general secretary is not even on television, but i would like lebediny to be broadcast on all channels in russia right now, right? it's okay here, but for them, for us, we have to look at the world soberly, tchaikovsky is a russian composer in the whole world, we can't make him ukrainian, and we don't need to, we have our own, and we have to do our own, as he said our classics, there is something to be proud of, and more, again, it is an imperial complex, and here, for example, did i shed recently, and another long topic, very briefly. she is very promoting now

ukrainian music, he tries to do it, but there are no ukrainian masterpiece operas there, let's say classical ones of the 19th and 20th centuries, well , there aren't, then there aren't, but i, it's difficult for me in the area of ​​music, i'm not there, not so much in the material, let's say , there are a large number, if it is already in the sphere of my competence, there are a large number of beautiful, successful european nations that do not have their original own. philosophy and what? nothing, they live well, have their own literature, moreover, the recognition that we do not have something is a guarantee that that it will appear, how does a fantastic czech novel of the second half of the 20th century arise? prague was all german-speaking at the beginning of the 20th, at the end of the 19th, who is associated with prague, first of all caucasians, or the same meinrich who writes novels about prague, in german, it is austria, after all, but the awareness that this is so... already in the second, in the second half of the 20th century, it gave rise to the phenomenon of kundera, the phenomenon of grabal, and this

world-class fantastic novel, that is, this is the way, but we must honestly say, here we have it, and we are proud of this, it is ours, it is ambiguous here, the very same one of ours can be in some ways a hero, in some ways a tramp, but here we just have a vacuum, we don’t have this, we don’t have it, and we have to calmly admit it and work on it, so be it, thank you for this conversation. a short, true conversation, the most interesting always begins when you have to finish the program, thank you for the conversation, vakhtan kybululadze, philosopher and writer was a guest of the program proper names, we will see you in a week, thank you, there are discounts on dolgit cream and dolgit gel, up to 30% in podoro pharmacies.

vasyl zima's big broadcast, this is a big broadcast, my name is vasyl zima, and we are starting, two hours of air time, two hours of your time, many important topics we will discuss with you today, two hours to learn about the war, right now and about the war let's talk more, serhii zgurets is with us, and how the world is living, now about what... happened in the world, yuriy fizar, yuriy dobrovech will speak in more detail, please give me the floor, two hours to keep up with economic news , time for to talk about money during the war, oleksandr morchivka is with us, oleksandr, welcome, please, and sports news, a review of sports events from yevhen pastukhov, two hours in the company of favorite presenters. thank you very much to elina chechenna for the information about cultural news, presenters that have become familiar to many. natalka didenko is ready to tell us about the weather on the day before, as well as the distinguished guests of the studio. andriy parubiy, people's deputy. was also chairman of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. events of the day in two hours. vasyl's big broadcast

winters a project for smart and caring people. espresso in the evening. the premium sponsor of the national team represents. united by football. stronger together, exclusively on the air of our channel. greetings, friends, the politclub on the espresso tv channel airs the most relevant topics of the week: russia's war against ukraine, the war in the middle east, the crisis on the border between ukraine and poland. topics that resonate in our society. drone attack on kyiv and other cities of ukraine, drone attacks on... moscow and other cities of russia, analysis of processes changing the country and each of us the country should get the right

to start negotiations on joining the eu. vitaly portnikov and guests of the project: we are bored, because there is nothing to fight about, let's invent, they help to understand the present and predict the future. for the world, a second trump presidency will be terrifying. a project for those who care and think. political club. every sunday at 20:10 at espresso. greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we have already come to the snake itself. the following shots may shock you. news from the scene. political analytics objectively and meaningful, there is no political season, exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest points of the front, a shot, svoboda life - frankly and impartially, you draw your own conclusions. watch this week

's judicial control program with tatyana shustrova. judges in the service of the kremlin. who found an approach to the ukrainian themis? oleksandr babakov is putin's confidant. but what violations did the board of the northern appellate economic court commit, handing over the poltava gzk to russian raiders. the decision is made by an absolutely corrupt component. greetings, you see judicial control, i'm tatyana shustrova. the judicial reform in ukraine is ongoing, soon, a qualification assessment of all the servants of themis must be carried out for compliance with the criteria of goodness. honesty and professional ethics, obviously not everyone will pass it, and until this happens, judges continue to surprise us, not only with cloud fortunes, but also with extremely absurd decisions, others run away from their positions, until the qualification committee found them unfit and dismissed them in disgrace . today we will tell you

about those who especially stood out, and first to the news. the supreme council of justice dismissed the judge of the kuznytsovsky city court valery malkov, who was prosecuted for drunken driving. for the first time, malkov was pulled over for drunk driving in august 2019. then he collided with a vase while driving a foreign car in varasha. at the same time, malkov had clear signs of alcohol intoxication, but refused to undergo a medical examination. no need to be rude here. what is this - i'm not going to press pause. there are documents in the car. i can car. there is a smell of alcohol, did you drink today, no, i did i don't have this car. did you drink before you hit that car or after? i didn't hit that car . the court found

malkov guilty, imposed a fine of uah 10,000 and deprived him of the right to drive a car for a year, however, for a year in august... the servant of themis was caught drunk again. the supreme council of justice decided that such behavior of malkov is not compatible with the status of a judge. another traitor judge was sent for dismissal. the second disciplinary chamber of the supreme council of justice recommended the dismissal of the judge of the kherson district administrative court , serhiy varniak. in august 2022, due to the russian occupation of kherson, the judge was assigned to work at the odesa district administrative court, but varniak never got there. instead, after deoccupation. kherson moved to the still temporarily occupied left bank of the kherson region, where he received a russian identification number and a pension. the final decision on the dismissal of the traitor from the post of ukrainian judge must now be made by the supreme council of justice. ukraine is in full swing rebooting the judicial system. competitions are being held to fill vacant positions in courts

of first instance and appeals, and the selection of judges for the constitutional court is ongoing. in parallel with these processes, a qualification assessment takes place. in accordance with the positions of the current servants of themis, especially resourceful ones try to escape into retirement as soon as possible, so that they are not expelled for violations, because judicial resignation is not just a pension, it is an extension of immunity and huge lifetime cash payments from the state, and until it is the turn to administer justice , there are still judges with very dubious reputations and sky-high fortunes that cannot be explained by official income. this is lyudmila kropyvna, a judge of the northern economic court of appeal. recently, she is very afraid for her safety, forbids journalists to film her despite the fact that she is a public figure. and according to our information, he travels accompanied by security. we do not know what scared the judge so much, but we really want to know about the origin of the funds that allowed her to purchase a large house in the suburbs of kyiv, an elite cottage town in kozen. koncha zaspa is a favorite

residence of the political and business elite of ukraine. there is a lake, a river, parks, private beaches and in general. very picturesque place. at the end of 2021, lyudmila kropyvna bought a 260 m2 house with a gazebo and a pool and 20 acres of valuable land here. homes of the same area with a large living room and fireplace, kitchen, dining room, three bedrooms and a sauna cost from $1 million here in the sudje neighborhood. however, the price of lyudmila kropyvna's house turned out to be almost eight times lower and amounts to slightly more than uah 5 million. it should be noted that by law state officials. including judges, are ineligible for individual discounts other than those available to all. so, if an official buys something at below-market prices, it can be considered an improper reward. or , in simple language, a bribe, and this is another judge of the northern commercial court of appeal , svitlana aldanova, and she also has a habit of underestimating the value of property. a few years

ago, she bought a toyota rav-4 for allegedly $600, when the market value was from $25. today , svitlana aldanova is a millionaire judge, according to with a declaration, he has almost 2 million hryvnias in his bank account, he keeps another 2 million in cash. lyudmila kropyvna and svitlana aldanova made illegal decisions in a high-profile case about... the raider seizure in favor of the russians of one of the giants of the ukrainian economy, the poltava mining and beneficiation plant. at the same time , the elite property of kropyvna in kozyna appeared precisely after she, as a member of the collegium , began to consider the case of the transfer of gzk shares to raiders. the third judge from the collegium is larisa zubets, who has already changed her last name and is now her ivanova, managed to escape to retirement. if you cannot count on a fair court decision, then how can you do business in ukraine? and if? there is also the russian factor, well, it creates, especially now, during the war, an additional negative connotation.

for more than one year, businessmen associated with the kremlin systematically pressured and destroyed the mining and metallurgical business, which is extremely important for the economy of ukraine, through the courts. and the undemanding ukrainian themis blessed raiding attempts even in the midst of war. despite billions in taxes, which companies paid to the budget. ferexpo group, which includes poltava mining. the enrichment plant paid almost uah 8 billion in 2022-23 alone and is one of the largest ukrainian exporters. in september 2022, the panel of judges of the northern commercial court of appeal, consisting of kropyvna zubets and aldanova, by its decision , contrary to the law, gave more than 40% of the shares of poltava gzk to former shareholders who owned the enterprise more than 20 years ago. four offshore companies that were part of the russian group. that is, in the midst of it of russia's full-scale war against ukraine , almost half of the shares went to the russians. the current

deputy chairman of the russian state duma , oleksandr babakov, together with his companion yevhen giner, president of the central sports club of the russian army, tried to seize control of the enterprise. judges pugs were happy to help them in this. the decision is made absolutely with a corruption component. ugh. and the fact that the courts make absurd decisions very often, and in fact investors and business owners can hope for a higher instance, to the supreme court, or in general to international courts, it definitely does not mean that it is normal. babakov is known not only for the fact that he voted for the annexation of crimea, the introduction of troops into ukraine and recognition. he is currently wanted by the sbu and under sanctions of ukraine, the usa and the eu, and a criminal case is being investigated in the united states for the implementation of hostile political plans against

ukraine and the usa. oleksandr babakov is a pensioner who, as a deputy, voted for the annexation of crimea. currently , this is the deputy chairman of the state duma of russia, this co-adviser, this is putin's confidant. the second person is also a citizen of the russian federation, yevhenii giner. he is... a member of the csk football club. cska stands for central sports club of the army of the russian federation. giner is also wanted and under us sanctions. in addition, he is a partner of the russian corporation rostec, which exports military products and is headed by an old friend of vladimir putin, sergei chemizov. in the fall of 2023, the sbu notified chemizov, who, in particular, supplies daggers for strikes on ukraine, on suspicion of russian financing. all aircraft that are produced, they are produced in our facilities, all brands of aircraft, it is an engine company that produces all

engines, in particular for space, aircraft, helicopters and ships, both civil and military. the ukrainian state bureau of investigation directly calls babakov and giner the leaders of the organized crime group archers, as stated in the joint investigation of the schema program on radio liberty and the scaner project. according to the conclusions of the sbi the specified group of russian citizens illegally obtained a number of objects of ukrainian critical infrastructure through fraud. the poltava gzk turned out to be another strategic object, control over which kremlin businessmen, the wallets of russian aggression, tried to seize control of, and a trio of ukrainian judges helped them in this. the pakhs board consists of lyudmila kropyvna, svitlana aldanova and larisa zubets. this is how, apparently, by bribing the ukrainian themis, the leader of the raiders, the vice-speaker of the russian state duma. babakov in the program of propagandist solovyov disposed of stolen ukrainian assets. turning to the new territories, i want to say that the expenses should not go there from

the budget of russia. we must consider these three. as economically ready to implement there. production there is the future income of both these territories and russia, in particular, and we should invest there, not based on our budget capabilities, but based on the capabilities of the economy of these territories. however , luzhnikovsky did not manage to manage the poltava mining and beneficiation plant for a long time. forkspo last year managed to defend her rights. the grand chamber of the supreme court canceled the decision of the northern court of appeal. actually admitting that... judges kropyvna, zubets and aldanova made mistakes when giving the enterprise to the russians. without any legal grounds and contrary to authority, they changed the subject of the dispute and went beyond the scope of reviewing the case. the motivational and resolutive part of the pachs ruling were contradictory and based on mutually exclusive conclusions. also, a trio of judges led by kropyvna intervened in property rights of the farexpo company, replacing non-existent shares with existing ones in the resolution, and also knowingly and

without reason ignored it. government prescriptions and legal norms, and was guided by assumptions instead of evidence. at the same time, having taken 40% of the shares from the legal owners, the judges left in the possession of the plaintiff and third parties the funds received by them for the sold and contested shares - 27 million dollars. so, thanks to the pax resolution , kremlin businessmen not only got richer by 27 million, but also actually received the nettle shares awarded by the troika for free poltava gzk with a total cost of 1,240. uah 1 million therefore, a year ago, by the decision of the grand chamber of the supreme court, the decisions of kropyvna, aldanova and zubets were canceled. and the shares of poltava gzk were transferred to the legal owner of ferexpo. the private center of the division of partners and the press network company will be partially satisfied. the decision of the public appellate commercial court of september 12, 2022 in case 910/251/2 was annulled. interestingly,

shortly after the supreme court put dotted in this case, four offshore raider companies self-liquidated, everything indicates that they were created specifically for this arrangement, and the decision of the pugs panel is due to the corrupt influence of the russians, that since the 19th year we have not reformed the judiciary, we have not cleared the bar of first-instance cases and the second instance of the court and the first instance and the appeal, many examples of absolutely... let's say absurd decisions, abuse of the decision, when it turns out that similar raids can be organized on this company, when they can seize it, and in essence, to take management hostage when they can block and paralyze conscious activities, this very significantly separates ukraine from the world. ferrexpo is listed on the london stock exchange, and poltava gzk is considered one of

the most attractive investment objects. markets, so the actions surrounding it are not only a blow to the state's economy in the midst of russian aggression, but also to the investment climate of ukraine. an attempt to put pressure on foreign investors may also affect international aid to ukraine in wartime conditions, and illegal actions pocket judges in these fights without rules endanger the entire judicial reform, which is a key condition for the further movement of ukraine to the european union. for today , that's all i have, this... there was judicial control and i'm tetyana shustrova. if you want to report corrupt judges or illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to this email address. see you in exactly a week. good bye. try flebodia

600. pink french pills for acute hemorrhoids. lebodia 600. treat hemorrhoids without any side effects. premium sponsor of the national team represents united by football. stronger together. the war continues. and not only for. territory, it is also a war for minds. russia is throwing millions of petrodollars into turning ukrainians into little russians. countering the information attacks of the russians in the information war chronicle project with olga ley. tuesday-thursday at 17:15, repeat, tuesday-friday at 22:00. verdict with serhii

rudenko. now there's even more in the new two-hour format.