in the important games yesterday, iraq beat australia by 6, uzbekistan beat saudi arabia by 3. club football in europe, real's big step to the championship with the victory against barcelona. in the thirty-second week of this competition, real madrid defeated sardellona last night in the most sensitive match in santiago bernabeu . with this victory, angeluti's students have 81 points and are 6 points away from the end of the season. reject their differences with barça.

dear viewers, this is the end of this news series. thank you very much for your attention and i wish you a good day.

up until today, wherever we are, you are more formal in the name of god, greetings, courtesy and respect , dear and respected viewers of the above program , we are at your service with another debate. you know that these days the discussion of adding a holiday to the weekly holidays is very hot. obviously, if we want to discuss , i would like to tell you about the issue of the sights of your service. it is whether we should close thursdays or saturdays , that is, in addition to fridays being closed, which day should we choose as the second day off, as you know those who agree with closing thursdays. they say, well, the conditions of the country are such that, for example, in a place like tehran, almost all offices are partially closed until the afternoon, for example, i don't work much , they don't work like other days, so let's continue the same process , it's better for now, for example, schools are closed on thursday. on the other side, those who

are in favor of closing on saturdays are most of our businessmen . i argue because the international and global holidays are on sundays and saturdays. if we close fridays and saturdays, those are the days we work from sunday to thursday. ok , it is closer to the world trade, our trade is easier and our communication with the world is more during working days, these are two arguments that obviously have a lot to discuss can we want this part of this debate? let's talk about it above and see what are the reasons of each side of the debaters. please stay with us until the bottom. here in the upper studio, mr. babaei karnami, a member of the social commission, is present , and a member of parliament is present in front of them, mr. keshani, the head of the isfahan chamber of commerce. mr. keshani is against the closure . saturdays are closed

, karnami is present on our side, and karnami is on the opposite side. let me start with the question of where the closure of my business has reached and what is the reason why it was emphasized by the representatives more in the social commission on thursdays. dear guests of your program , i would like to thank you from the chamber of commerce and for your good program. criticism remained in the public conversations of the society in the media and from the perspective of various experts. just review and

it is a serious investigation and therefore, from this point of view, well, considering that the respected government sent a layer in line with the implementation of this public demand of the society, the layer of the government with priority in accordance with the internal bylaws of the islamic shura majlis has been ordered by the islamic majlis to vote in its entirety. it was sent to the social commission , which is a specialized commission. the specialized commission is also based on the so-called investigations with the research center of the parliament, the information that the society has, the private sectors , the target group, the target audience group, in fact, this is a big goal in the country. especially the private and public sectors , well, finally, the necessary measures are being taken this is an important point for us . first of all, in the bill that the government sent to the islamic council, i would like to ask you

that it did not specify the days. it has become a 40-hour work week, and the parliament should have commented on this, of course, with my comments, which we will present to you later in the program, god willing. well, with the same approach, the majlis sent a vote in the elani session of the majlis in kliatsham, and entered into the details. i raised some doubts with some of our colleagues the format of the proposals that they send is based on the internal regulations of the islamic council, well, based on that again, the honorable chairman of the meeting got confused and sent it to the commission. it was here that the new proposals of the representatives were put forward. in fact, the two-polarity of the islamic parliament itself and in the society started a series of representatives and a series of its target group. in fact, outside the parliament and the government , there are also a series of supporters of this plan.

there are supporters of closing on thursdays, as a result of the commission 's discussion and investigations, with the opinions of the target group, the vote of closed on thursdays means that thursdays should be added to one more day off during the week . what was their reason? the reason they mentioned is that thursdays are currently closed due to the current state of holidays in the country in terms of labor productivity. it is practically not effective in economic growth , which means that the government spends one day a week on the basis of economic, social and cultural governance and structures. the cultural, social and even political founder and the approach that existed in our society based on those dimensions behind the scenes and in different states of the country, well panjshanba does not have the necessary efficiency, it has come with the same situation that it is not efficient, in fact

, it will not be used for half an hour in one day. so, he said that he should actually put this half-raised flag in order, and then make other decisions later , another reason why the parliament is discussing so-called. the opinion is that finally, the more diverse dimensions were discussed with the government, the honorable government and the representative of the government in the social commission, and his opinion was that it should be on thursdays . in the social commission, discussing and discussing with this view in the country is being reviewed and criticized god willing, it will be investigated in the shura council in the sunnis of the majlis , of course. i am a social worker at the service of the dear ones, and according to the general opinion of the social commission as a specialized commission, it has been concluded that we, as a servant of the dear ones

, will review and review the various aspects so that, god willing, it will be delayed in the summing up of the votes of the representatives in the sanni majlis, mr. keshani. tell me why you are against closing the day. thursdays are on saturdays and you say that you are sorry . you are against thursdays being closed. do you agree that in the name of god, i offer my greetings to his highness and all those involved and thank you you have entered into such an important issue , i would like to tell you that first of all, every issue that is brought up definitely has different dimensions. mr. doctor's business environment improvement law and chamber of commerce law, you have considered us as a three-way consultation

, and we have written many times to the members of the social commission, the speaker of the parliament, and the representatives . a good research has also been done since shahrivar, which has all been presented to his highness and much more it is strange that such an important decision is made in kamson and not

many of the government's activities are service activities such as hospitals, fire brigades , etc. manpower becomes the government, and you know it creates inflation, the burden of this inflation is on the shoulders of the people, and in the coming year, we all work together to increase production, and we hope that this will cause inflation. this has caused our inflation to increase. as a department, we especially support because we know how to pay interest to increase. from that side, i want gentlemen be sure to think that the government should manage this issue to prevent these negative effects in the lives of the public. i will fully explain that this economy

will harm the country's trade with the first 5 countries . our business is 110 billion dollars. especially , we found the working hours of our first 5 countries exactly. china, for example, has fourteen and a half trade relations with china we are dealing with the emirates, iraq, india, and turkey. yes , these five countries have calculated their common hours . the value of thursday has been included in it . it has been calculated exactly how much thursday is worth, and we have assumed that half of this number. maybe this is our assumption. if it is not true at all, half of this is possible for our business to return to that in 3 days

, the other half will not be able to return, maybe we will not be able to return in the same three days or even half of it, we will have 8 billion dollars of commercial losses in the country, this will definitely harm the country's business. the country's exports will suffer can you tell us how many business connections you have with foreign countries on thursdays and saturdays? now, i can tell you about china in particular, what happened in china and what you want to do now . let me ask mr. babai karnai. the number they are putting forward is not a small number. the commission of these commercial numbers has been raised, how many economic representatives of the economic commission, the number coming from the point of view of the private sector is respectable, we do not categorically reject it. the law that establishes, based on the research work

done in the research center of the islamic council , such a number of documents have not been openly displayed until now, so that the parliament will actually withdraw from its decision. besides, i have presented my arguments that i said clearly that the parliament is not necessarily looking for whether it should be thursday or saturday . let's close the week for now and come to a complete conclusion. of course, i was just coming today. is there any difference of opinion because the government itself passed the bill and you also approved it? did anyone else have a disagreement on this day ? so far, we are together. of course, i heard that recently , the honorable representative of the organization, the honorable deputy of the recruitment department, gave an interview to your colleagues. in fact , contrary to the rules and laws that he proposed, if it becomes a law, in my opinion, this layer of the government is totally in violation

of the loan, that is, it will directly negate the words of the deputy director of the employment organization based on the principles that the government itself has given to the parliament, that is, two days it is certain that there is an argument, for example first of all, let me defend these two days, the number of weekends and special occasions in most countries of the world is between 110 and 129 days, most of the countries of the world strike in iran on the same 26 days . there are also our researches with 26 days of official holidays and 5. it is not a high number of holidays, but if we make friday the 2nd day , the number of holidays in iran will reach 125 days, which means that we will soon reach the world standards.

the private sector itself will definitely be proven in the continuation of discussions in scientific charts, how much these two. i think it must be the intelligence of the government that it did not bring the day quickly, why the failure of the implementation should be in the hands of the government, because this law , while it is a permanent law, will definitely find an experimental infrastructure, so the government must convince itself to prepare the infrastructure in the country of the process, finally , our closure mechanisms are currently based on our foundations, in fact, formed in our educational structures

, in the structures of our big cities, in our micro-urban administrations, in our villages. iran with countries the climate and strategies that we look at in the future are actually different from what we have from an economic point of view, iran is different, but in fact, the issue of tribes of different social tribes is discussed in our country, not that many now. we, obviously, this is the heart of the government . we are discussing now on thursdays, why do you agree on thursdays? look, i have already said that i am discussing with the commission. an addition that mr. dr. mr. keshani said that the discussion of, for example, 7-8 billion dollars in the field of economy

for example, it is effective only on the day of the festival , unlike, for example, the opinion of thursdays, which must announce the numerical number, which, for example , they say that it will not have an economic effect. according to mr. doctor, they say five days off on thursdays, because the rest of the world is not a day off, except for djibouti. no other country is closed for half a day in djibouti, so the effect of our closing on thursday for 5 countries, our export target is 88 billion dollars, numbers and figures and exactly everything is ready here, i just didn't reject it. the first criticism of our doctor was why we are considered as the private sector that honorable members of our country's chamber of commerce in the meeting the social commission, in order to make this discussion final, because the opinion of dr. ghalibaf , the honorable chairman of the parliament, was the same as your discussion, we must

see the discussion and phenomena and indicators that are actually considered by the private sector in this law. . now you said that on thursdays , the commission did not come to the conclusion that thursdays are saturdays, there is no other reason than that it was not actually at the level of the government, we generally look at the level of the government. that thursday was caused by our commission, so that's what i'm saying i say, look, it was not the year of the government layer, i say, now this proposal was one of the representatives, you should give your opinion, you know, sir, the internal letter of the parliament is like this , the layer that it sends, for example, 48 hours per representative

, the official reporting center, the research center of the parliament and the official centers of the government, we do not ask for your opinion at all. let's deny it, we didn't come to this conclusion. you don't give us a report on how much, for example, 8 billion dollars will damage our country's economy if we are closed on thursday . official centers should officially tell us this number . it is official for us, and generally our parliament will accept it , mr. you as a pawn are the law of conversation it is you who, if you have memorized the law, mr. doctor, the law on improving the business environment , it is written there that the chamber of commerce is responsible for advising you

. we gave our advice to the commission. the official of the majlis research center should be discussed, we have subtraction and the budget of the court of accounts. the court of accounts is one of the tools that proves the subtraction of the smallest number . we are also at your service. by the way, your opinion is respected i will not reject your opinion immediately. i say that your opinion should go to yesterday's meeting of the bazaar chamber to the community commission . the representatives of the private sector should be 70% in general, it is necessary that we use their opinion, why before portraying that sometimes.

we will be closed on thursday because of our business hours , china is considered as one of our major trading partners. hours per week per year per year per year 650 hours even if we close saturday let's see 880 hours, mr. d. suppose we have three more days in a week. if it falls on thursday, we don't have three more days . if we have a chinese holiday , we will have a chinese holiday. for example, it is the month of february. we lose our connection with other countries . many countries and this will cause our trade to slow down, this will increase inflation , decrease export income and

change the economic environment of the country. increase how does production increase production? people who have more than they have can use , should it be exported? how does export happen? with the help of the private sector, with increasing interactions with the world , we cannot separate the economic ecosystem of the world , i say no, we think to ourselves. let the rest of the world think for itself that we should enter the world economic ecosystem, and the parliament should help the private sector to be present in the world economic ecosystem . this mr. doctor, this bill, this approval of thursday's closing, will seriously harm other countries as well. yes, let me tell you that now, i want to tell each and every country because of you , the most important reason why our businessmen

are currently working, and if we add another day off to our holidays, it means that they are working. we don't exactly lose 4 hours for china, 5 hours for iraq, 5 hours for turkey, 4 hours for the uae, 5 hours for india, and 4 hours for india . we can do business, business is a two-way interaction, and unfortunately, because our economy is very much a government economy, this is where the presence of the government is effective with the presence of banks. the effectiveness of banks must be present. the presence of exchange offices is effective. the trade organization is effective. the chamber of commerce is effective.

i invite you to come to an agreement and see a report together to see what the rest of the experts think about the closing on saturdays and thursdays. we will come back and continue the debate. the closing of thursdays is an example of a boycott, under these conditions , we take away the opportunity to interact with the world. the world stops cooperating. the private sector wants to cancel this appointment and replace saturday instead of thursday. pirouz ebrahimi, secretary of khorasan razavi mining and trade house. the days of rest of the week in the countries of the world are saturday and sunday, and

friday is a holiday in iran. the gap between the economies of the countries and the world economy is 3 days, but with the addition of thursday's holiday, this gap increases to 4 days. abolfazl abu tarabi, a member of the country's internal affairs commission and parliament councils , we are experiencing injustice during holidays in the country. on the one hand, the employees of the ministries of oil, energy, education, etc government employees in tehran are closed on thursday, and some in the cities must be at work. abdulreza azizi, head of the commission. social security of the parliament, this action is feasible and at least in the metropolis , we will see positive effects such as reducing air pollution, reducing traffic and reducing energy consumption. abdallah izadpanah, a member of the agriculture commission, approving the plan to close on saturday may cause problems in people's lives, and i think it is not a good thing to confront people's culture. yes

, we have seen the report together, mr. babaei, please tell me what your decision to close on thursday and saturday seems to be. well, as you said yourself , you didn't look at the economic aspects , you looked more at the social and cultural aspects, what was the most important thing, because a series of topics, for example, holidays on saturdays, for example, a religious minority, etc., were brought up. see , we all have to accept this now. in fact , we all agree with the organization in the functional reality or the current working hours of the country, that it has no social and cultural meaning , mr. kashai, that this point that he clearly stated in the discussion that, for example, declaring the economic number on saturday is related to the economy of our country, but it is connected to onor the economic council does not say this, i don't know why at least nefisho does not actually move in this direction, the reason is why you are talking about productivity continuums or discussions related to, for example, the pollution of tehran.

excuse me, if you have the report of the research center, if you have it, please tell us the difference between closing thursdays and saturdays in the economic field. i am saying that the link with the economic approach has not been examined. the parliament has not entered into this discussion at all. in fact , the point of the day, the point of the day, in fact, i can clearly see in the approach that is being followed up in the parliament, is that we are in fact with the approach. we prioritized culture and society, and we all agreed to have two days off in a week and go in such a direction that in fact , human resources know their duties and work from saturday to wednesday with very high productivity. on average , nirostani is at work from saturday to thursday, due to shift work and holidays, and some of the issues we have, in fact

, it is not really two hours or more. i apologize for not reporting. the research center would convince you to close on thursdays instead of saturdays or vice versa at all and later for the time being , the hayard research center will not enter into this discussion because it has not been discussed, because i mentioned that it should not be included in this discussion. it was not the purpose of the parliament to say directly whether it was thursday or saturday . i saw some of our colleagues in your expert report . well, it seems that we are good colleagues . we agreed and disagreed, but the principle was that in reality

,